Zagros Archaeological Researches

Zagros Archaeological Researches

Probable Evidence of a Middle Paleolithic Site in the Northern part of Susiana Plain, Khuzestan, Iran

Document Type : Original Article

Author
Archaeologist
Abstract
Abstract
Despite extensive studies on Pleistocene human activities in the Zagros and Alborz regions, as well as significant progress in the study of areas such as foothills, plains, and desert margins in recent years, some of these marginal and foothill areas have still received less attention and limited information has been obtained about the Paleolithic period from them. Among these areas, we can mention Khuzestan province, especially the northern areas of this province (northern heights of the Shushan plain), which despite the limited paleolithic studies conducted in recent years, the information obtained from this area seems interesting. The Khervali site is one of the few known paleolithic sites in recent years, located in the west of the Zagros highlands, in the northern heights of Shush city, and near the western bank of the Karkheh River. This site was identified and systematically investigated in 2012. Given the size of the site and the distribution of the tools, sampling the entire site was not possible, so only four areas of the entire site were selected for sampling, and a total of 330 stone tool fragments were collected from these areas. The results of the analysis of the tools from this site indicate an assemblage probably related to the Middle Paleolithic period with the prevalence of chipping techniques, along with the presence of Loval elements and scraping types, and with significant access to local raw materials.
Keywords: Khervali, Middle Paleolithic, North of the Shushan Plain, Conglomerate Formation, Access to raw materials.
Introduction
Despite extensive studies on Pleistocene human activities in the Zagros and Alborz regions, as well as significant progress in the study of areas such as foothills, plains, and desert margins in recent years, some of these marginal and foothill areas have still received less attention and limited information has been obtained about the Paleolithic period from them. Among these areas, we can mention Khuzestan Province, especially the northern areas of this province (northern heights of the Shushan Plain), which despite the limited paleolithic studies conducted in recent years, the information obtained from this area seems interesting. The Khervali site is one of the few known paleolithic sites in recent years, located in the west of the Zagros highlands, in the northern heights of Shush County, and near the western bank of the Karkheh River. Topographically, this area is an open valley with a relatively flat surface and a gentle northwest-southeast slope, located in an area consisting of several prominent hills known as the Khervali Hills on the geological maps of the Iranian Oil Company. From a geological perspective, it seems that this area, due to its higher elevation above the plain, was spared from the sedimentation process prevailing in the Khuzestan Plain and the Holocene sedimentary deposits and was formed directly on the Bakhtiari Conglomerate Formation, and its bed is covered with rounded sandstone cobbles of various sizes and abundant pieces of chert. Given the importance of the subject and the unknown status of the Paleolithic period in this area, a systematic study of this area was the main focus of the work. In order to investigate this area, due to the vastness of the area, the damage done to the area, and the time constraints, it was not possible to map and grid the area with mapping cameras. Accordingly, after surveying the entire area and carefully assessing the density and distribution of artifacts, four locations in sections with an altitude higher than the dry river bed that were protected from the natural sedimentation process and also from the damage caused by excavation operations were selected for sampling. To facilitate the recording and processing of samples taken from different collections, after recording the geographical coordinates of each point using GPS, a number was assigned to each collection, which ultimately created four circular areas with a diameter of 20 meters, named Locus 1, 3, 4, and 5. A total of 330 pieces of stone tools, including the mother rock and pieces separated from it (Core/Core Fragment), blank debitage, tools, and debris, were collected from the aforementioned loci.

Discussion
After examining the stone tools, it was determined that the raw materials used in the Khervali Valley area include flint (pieces of chert, flint, jasper, opal) and rarely river rocks of sandstone and quartz. Most of the tools in the area are made of light brown, liver, and in some cases green and red, gray and cream flint. This type of raw material is the most important petrological feature of the Bakhtiari Conglomerate Formation, which mainly belongs to the Cretaceous, Eocene and Oligocene and its outcrops have been reported so far in the western Zagros regions, especially the northern areas of the Khuzestan plains of Dehloran and Mehran. As mentioned earlier, the aforementioned site is located on the Bakhtiari Conglomerate Formation and clearly indicates the direct access of the toolmakers to the raw stone material in the area itself and its easy exploitation for the production of tools. In terms of the chronology of the site, with the exception of the presence of cleavers/mother stones among the assemblage, due to the absence of the elements of the Old Paleolithic such as hand axes and adzes, and considering the very high frequency of the use of chipping technology, the presence of the Loval technique, the presence of scrapers and serrated/crested tools, and also the absence of the new Paleolithic industries such as end scrapers, chisels, numerous retouched blades, end scrapers and DuFour micro blades, it seems more logical to attribute this site to the Middle Paleolithic period. As mentioned, the foothill areas of the northern low plains of western and southwestern Iran have remained unknown or have received less attention compared to areas such as the Zagros and Alborz. Among these unknown areas, we can mention Khuzestan province. This province in general and its northern regions (Shushan Plain) in particular, despite their importance and special place in Iranian archaeological research. Unfortunately, information about the Paleolithic period of these areas is very scanty compared to later periods and is related to nascent research of the last few years. So far, sites related to different Paleolithic periods have been reported in this region (the buffer heights between the Shushan Plain and the western foothills of the Zagros), and the information obtained from them is interesting. The important point about these sites, in addition to their proximity to permanent rivers, is their location on the Bakhtiari Conglomerate Formation located in this intermediate region, which somehow indicates the connection of these sites with raw stone sources with high density and easy access

Conclusion
The newly discovered Khervali site is one of the few identified Paleolithic sites in the north of the Shushan Plain, which is important in two respects: first, its specific geographical location, i.e., its location between the Zagros Mountains and the Khuzestan Lowland as an intermediate site for which little information is available about its Paleolithic status; second, the direct and undoubted connection of this site with the raw stone resources in the region, which was formed directly on the Bakhtiari Conglomerate Formation with a dense concentration of raw stone. It seems that conducting specialized and targeted surveys in these areas to identify Paleolithic sites and analyze their settlement patterns in the overall landscape (upland and lowland areas) can provide interesting information about the distribution and adaptation of Pleistocene populations to their environment, the patterns used in the stone economy and the exploitation of raw material resources, as well as the possible role that these areas played between the highlands and the lowlands.
Keywords
Subjects

References
Adams. R. M., 1962. Agriculture and Urban Life in Early Southwestern Iran.
Science, New Series, Vol. 136, No. 3511, pp. 109- 122.
Aghanabati, Seyed Ali, 2006, Geology of Iran, 2nd ed., Tehran: Geological Survey and Mineral Exploration of Iran Publications. (in Persian)
Ahmadzadeh Shohani, Loqman, 2014, Archaeological Survey of the Western Boundary of the Karkheh River, Khuzestan, in Short Papers of the Twelfth Annual Symposium of Iranian Archaeology (19–21 May), Tehran: Research Institute of Cultural Heritage and Tourism, Iranian Cultural Heritage, Handicrafts and Tourism Organization, pp. 32–35. (in Persian)
Alibaigi. S., Niknami. K., Khosravi. S., 2010. A Preliminary Report on the Investigations of the Lower Paleolithic Site of Khaleseh in the Khoram Dareh Valley, Zanjan, Iranian Archaeology, Vol. 1, No. 1, pp. 8- 14.
Alipour, Mehdi and Mehrnaz Nadali Kahish, 2014, “Survey and Identification of Paleolithic Settlements in Northeastern Dezful,” in Short Papers of the Twelfth Annual Symposium of Iranian Archaeology (19–21 May), Tehran: Research Institute of Cultural Heritage and Tourism, Iranian Cultural Heritage, Handicrafts and Tourism Organization, pp. 310–312. (in Persian)
Alipour, Mehdi, 2012, Report on the Survey and Identification of Paleolithic Settlements in Northeastern Dezful, Khuzestan Provincial Office of Cultural Heritage and Tourism Industries (unpublished). (in Persian)
Alipour, Mehdi, 2014, Survey and Identification of Paleolithic Sites in Northeastern Dezful County, M.A. Thesis in Archaeology, Marlik Non-Profit University. (in Persian)
Bahramian, Saeid, 2014, Typo-Technological Study of the Lithic Assemblage from the Paleolithic Site KS1700 (Kharvali Hills) on the Western Margin of the Karkheh River, Khuzestan Province, M.A. Thesis in Archaeology, Faculty of Humanities, Tarbiat Modares University. (in Persian)
Bahramiyan. S., Ahmadzadeh Shouhani. L., 2016. Between Mountain and Plain: New Evidence for the Middle Palaeolithic in the Northern Susiana Plain, Khuzestan, Iran. Antiquity 90, 354, pp. 1- 6 (Project Gallery).
Barfi, Cyrus, 2011, “Report on the Survey of a Rockshelter with Paleolithic Remains at Kul-e Farah, Izeh,” Journal of Archaeology and History, Vol. 23, No. 2 (Serial No. 46), pp. 10–14. (in Persian)
Biglari, Fereidoun and Sonia Shidrang, 2011, “Paleolithic Settlements in the Western Foothills of the Zagros: New Evidence from the Sar Qaleh Bāvīsi Region (Azgeleh), Western Kermanshah,” Iranian Archaeology, No. 2, Tehran: International Institute for Tourism Studies and Hasht Mina Publications, pp. 9–27. (in Persian)
Biglari, Fereidoun, 2003, “Nargeh: The First Evidence of the Middle Paleolithic in the Qazvin Plain, Northwestern Central Plateau of Iran,” Archaeological Reports 2, Archaeological Research Center, pp. 165–171. (in Persian)
Biglari, Fereidoun, 2004, “Preliminary Survey Report of Paleolithic Sites in the Kashan Region,” in Silver Workers of Sialk: Report of the Second Season of the Sialk Reassessment Project, edited by Sadegh Malek Shahmirzadi, Tehran: Archaeological Research Center, pp. 151–168. (in Persian)
Biglari. F., Javeri. M., mashkour. M., yazdi. M., Shidrang. S., Tengberg. M., Taheri. K., and Darvish. J., 2009. Test excavations at the Middle Paleolithic Sites of Qaleh Bozi, southwest of central Iran, a preliminary report. In: Iran Palaeolithic / Le Paléolithique d’Iran, M. Otte, F. Biglari and J. Jaubert (eds.), Oxford, Bar International series. pp. 29- 38.
Biglari. F., Nokandeh. G., Heydari Guran. S., 2000. A recent find of a Possible Lower Paleolithic assemblage from the foothills of the Zagros Mountains. Antiquity 74, pp. 749- 50.
Conard. N. J., Ghasidian. E., Heydari Guran. S., 2009. The Open-air Epipaleolithic Site of Bardia and Paleolithic Occupation of the Qaléh Gusheh Sand Dunes, Esfahan Province, Iran. In: Iran Paleolithic / Le Paléolithique d’Iran, M. Otte., F. Biglari and J. Jaubert (eds.), Oxford, Bar International Series. pp. 141- 154.
Darabi. H., Javanmardzadeh. A., Beshkani. A., Jami-Alahmadi. M., 2012. Paleolithic occupation of the Mehran Plain in Southwestern of Iran. Documenta Prehistorica XXXIX, pp. 443- 451.
Darvishzadeh, Ali, 1991, Geology of Iran, Tehran: Danesh-e Emrouz Publications (affiliated with Amir Kabir Publications). (in Persian)
Dinarvand. Y., Mehranpour. H., 2015. Paleolithic Open-air Sites, North of Susiana Plain in South West Iran, Khuzestan Province, East of Dez River. Ancient Asia, 6: 6, pp. 1- 4.
Dinarvand. Y., Mortazavi. M., Mehranpoor. H., Yazdanfar. A., Alipoor. M., Khodabakhshi Parizi. M., Ahmadzadeh Shohani. L., 2012. A Paleolithic Survey around the Dez River in Southwestern Iran. 4th international congress of the society of south Asian Archaeology, 15- 17 April, Zahedan, Iran, pp. 43.
Ghirshman, Roman, 1993, Iran from the Earliest Times to Islam, 9th ed., translated by Mohammad Mo'in, Tehran: Elmi va Farhangi Publications. (in Persian)
Girshman. R., 1949. Campagne de fouilles ẚ Suse en 1948- 1949. Comptes rendus des Séances de l›Académie des Inscriptions ET Belles-lettres, No. 3 pp. 196- 199.
Girshman. R., 1951.  L›Iran des origions a l›Islam. Paris, Payot.
Heydari Guran. S., Ghasidian. E., 2011. Paleolithic Survey in Arisman Region: Western Central Iranian Plateau. In: Early Mining and Metallurgy on the Western Central Iranian Plateau, A. Vatandoust., H. Parzinger and B. Helwing (eds.), Archäologie in Iran und Touran Band 9. Mainz: Verlag Plilip von Zebern. pp.  484- 498.
Heydari Guran. S., Ghasidian. E., Conard. N. J., 2009. Paleolithic sites on Travertine and Tufa formations in Iran. In: Iran Paleolithic / Le Paléolithique d’Iran, M. Otte, F. Biglari and J. Jaubert (eds.), Oxford: Bar International series. pp. 109- 124.
Heydari Guran. S., Ghasidian. E., Conard. N. J., 2015. Middle Paleolithic Settlement on the Iranian Central Plateau. In: Settlement Dynamics of the Middle Paleolithic and Middle Stone Age, Volume IV, N. J. Conard., and A. Delagnes (eds.), Tübingen Publications in Prehistory. pp. 171- 203.
Heydari. S., 2004. Stone Raw Material Sources in Iran: Some Case Studies. In Persiens antike Pracht: Bergbau, Handwerk, Archäologie: Katalog der Ausstellung des Deutschen Bergbau Museums Bochum vom 28. November 2004 bis 29. Mai 2005, T. Stöllner, R. Slotta, and A. Vatandoust (eds.). 2 vols. Bochum: Deutsches Bergbau-Museum.
Iranian Oil Operating Companies., 1967. Geological and Exploration Division, Tehran: “DEZFUL”. Geological Compilation Map 1:100,000, Drawing No: 25470 W.
Jaiz, Mozhgan, 2007, Identification and Spatial Analysis of Stone Age Sites in the Izeh Plain, M.A. Thesis in Archaeology, Faculty of Literature and Humanities, University of Tehran. (in Persian)
Jaiz, Mozhgan, Khadijeh Molamirzaei and Kamal al-Din Niknami, 2013, “Report on Stone Age Sites in the Piyun Plain, Southwestern Iran,” Iranian Archaeology, No. 4, Tehran: International Institute for Tourism Studies and Hasht Mina Publications, pp. 23–40. (in Persian)
Jayez. M., Niknami. K., Molla Mirzai. Kh., 2012. Report on the Discoveries of New Stone Age Sites in the Plain of Pion, South-Western of Iran. 4th international congress of the society of south Asian Archaeology, 15- 17 April, Zahedan, Iran, p. 46.
Mecquenem. R. De., 1943. Fouilles de Suse 1993-1939. M.M.A.XXIX, pp. 140-142.
Niknami. K., Jayez. M., Salahshour. N., 2009. New Epipalaeolithic- Protoneolithic Sites on the Izeh Plain, South-western Iran, Antiquity 83, issue 321, (Project Gallery.
Olszewski. D., Dibble. H. L., 2006. To be or not to be Aurignacian: The Zagros Upper Paleolithic. In: Towards a Definition of the Aurignacian. O. Bar-Yosef., and J. Zilhao (eds.), Proceedings of the Symposium Held in Lisbon, Portugal, June 25-30, 2006, pp. 355- 373.
Sardari Zarchi, Alireza, 2013, Report on the Archaeological Survey and Identification of Andika County, Vol. 2, Part 1, Khuzestan Provincial Office of Cultural Heritage, Tourism and Handicrafts. (in Persian)
Sardari Zarchi, Alireza, 2014, “Archaeological Survey and Identification of Masjed Soleyman and Andika Counties: A Case Study of Cultural Interactions between the Zagros Highlands and the Lowlands,” in Short Papers of the Twelfth Annual Symposium of Iranian Archaeology (19–21 May), Tehran: Research Institute of Cultural Heritage and Tourism, Iranian Cultural Heritage, Handicrafts and Tourism Organization, pp. 267–270. (in Persian)
Shea. J. J., 2013. Stone Tools In the Paleolithic and Neolithic Near East, A
Guide
. Cambridge University Press.
Sheikh, Mohammad, n.d., Paleolithic Survey of the Susa Plain in the Karkheh River Basin, Khuzestan Provincial Office of Cultural Heritage, Handicrafts and Tourism. (in Persian)
Shen. Ch., 1997. Towards A Comprehensive Understanding of the Lithic
Production System of the Princess Point Complex, Southwestern Ontario. Phd Dissertation, University of Torento, Canada.
Shidrang. S., 2009. A Typo-Technological Study of an Upper Paleolithic Collection from Sefid-Ab, Central Iran. In: Iran Palaeolithic/ Le Paléolithique d’Iran, M. Otte, F. Biglari, and J. Jaubert (eds.). Oxford: Bar International series. pp. 47- 56.
Shoaee. M, J., Vahdati Nasab. H., Storozum. M., Frenzel. P., Akhavan Kharazian. M., Fernandes. R., Hashemi. S, M., Jayez. M., Amano. N., Marzban Abbasabadi. B., Aalipoor. M., Lucas. M., Marzo. S., llgner. J., Patalano. R., Roberts. P., Boivin. N., Petraglia. M., 2024. Initial Upper Paleolithic in the Zagros Mountains. Front Earth Sci.12:1352099. doi: 10.3389/feart.2024.1352099.
Vahdati Nasab. H., 2011. Paleolithic Archaeology of Iran. International Journal of Humianities, Vol. 18 (2), pp. 63- 87.
Vahdati Nasab. H., Clark. G, A., Torkamandi. S., 2013. Late Pleistocene Dispersal Corridors Across the Iranian Plateau: A case study from Mirak, A Middle Paleolithic Site on the Northern Edge of the Iranian Central Desert (Dasht-e Kavir). Quaternary International, Volume 300: pp. 267- 281.
Vahdati Nasab. H., Hashemi. M., 2016. Playas and Middle Paleolithic settlement of the Iranian Central Desert: The discovery of the Chah-e Jam Middle Paleolithic site. Quaternary International 408, pp. 140- 152.
Vahdati Nasab. H., Mollasalehi. H., Saeedpour. M., Jamshidi. J., 2009. Paleolithic Levalloisian Assemblages from Boeen Zahra in the Qazvin Plain, Iran, Antiquity 83, 320, (Project Gallery).
Vahdati Nasab. H., Roustaei. K., Rezvani. H., 2010. Delazian (Mirak I): Evidence of Paleolithic Settlement at the Northern Edge of the Iranian Central Desert. In: Proceedings of the 6th Archaeology of the Ancient Near East, Vol. 2, P. Matthiae., F. Pinnock., L. Nigro., and N. Marchetti (eds.), Università di Roma ‘La Sapienza’, Roma.
Wenke. R. J., 1975-76. Imperial Investment and Agricultural Developments in
Parthian and Sasanian Khuzestan: 150 B.C. to A.D. 640. Mesopotamia 10-11,
pp. 31- 221.
Wojtczak. D., 2014. The Early Middle Palaeolithic Blade Industry from Hummal, Central Syria. Phd Dissertation, Basel University.
Wright. H. T., (ed.), 1979. Archaeological investigations in Northeastern Xuzestan. 1976, Research Reports in Archaeology: Contribution 5, Technical Report 10. Museum of Anthropology, The University of Michigan. Ann Arbor.
Zeynivand. M., 2017. An Acheulean Biface from the Deh Luran Plain, Iran. Antiquity 91, 357, pp. 1-5 (Project Gallery).
 
 
 
Volume 1, Issue 2 - Serial Number 2
December 2024
Pages 1-18

  • Receive Date 06 March 2025
  • Revise Date 14 April 2025
  • Accept Date 16 April 2025